People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We came here on date night and it was a great experience. We sat at the bar with a clear view of the wood oven to watch the cooks. My husband ordered an Italian beer and I ordered a sangria. We enjoyed our drinks! One of the best sangrias I have had, included cut up strawberries and grapefruit. For an appetizer, we ordered Diane’s Chicken Meatballs, it was melt in your mouth delicious! The sauce and cheese were a great addition to the juicy meatballs. We also ordered a Caesar Salad, it was so large, could feed 3 people. It was a good quality cheese and croutons. It did not too much dressing. We both ordered personal pizzas, queen margarita and NY cheese with mushrooms added. This is the best pizza I have had in this area by far! It’s thin crust, wood oven cooked to perfection. For dessert, we split the cheesecake with Caramel drizzle on top with whipped cream. It was so good and melt in your mouth! Our waitress was friendly and took our order and checked on us at the right time. She was pleasant with each request we had, extra side of sauce, extra plates, and a box to go with leftovers. She was smiling and professional. I would highly recommend! Great atmosphere, great food, great service! ”
“ Amazing from beginning to end!!! We are vacationing and thought we’d try Margherita Pizza Co on our last night in town.... We are SO disappointed we didn’t try it out first night because we would have eaten here several times throughout our stay! Staff were fantastic and food was fresh and FULL of flavor!! Thank you for a wonderful end to our vacation!! We will definitely be back next year! ”
“ Amazing. Fresh, delicious thin crust pizza and wood fired taste. Everything was quality and made quickly - we had a large order and it was ready within 20 mins! Great customer service and nice setting inside, will definitely be back. ”
“ NY style Cheese pizza in photo, (with one bite taken out of it, lol). This is a really cute restaurant, that is well run, and clean. It has an open kitchen where you can watch them making your pizzas. They have high chairs for the little ones, European sodas and beers, and a delicious Caesar salad that is big enough for two! Each person gets their own personal pizza, which was plenty for the adults in our party. They offer gelato, and limoncello cake, that I really wanted to try, but I was too full. Maybe next time! Great wood-fired pizza!! ”
“ We were on vacation looking for great pizza with atmosphere & we found it! It’s going on our vacation list of favorite restaurants! My husband the “ Chef” of the family gave it a huge thumbs up ”
“ Our waiter was so silly and kind! He made our dining experience and the atmosphere so great even when I drunkenly roasted the pizza comparing it to traditional NY pizza. This is a 5-star review and also an apology to our waiter! “Sorry about the peppas!” ”
“ Best pizza in the county! And we have tried them all. Taste great and all the fresh ingredients out of the brick oven was Amazing. Atmosphere is a plus! The staff was friendly! Will definitely go back for sure! Under 50.00 for the 3 of us! ”
“ This is a really great place for pizza. There's wide variety of personal pizza's and you can't go wrong with any of them. The flavors combinations in the pizzas are fantastic, especially the vodka sauce with sausage pizza. Wine selection was good and a good variety of beer to include local beers. Staff is fast, efficient and genuinely good friendly people. Highly recommend for great food and great atmosphere ”
Menu
Antipasto
US$14.00Pure Leaf UNSWEET Tea
US$4.00Boylan Black Cherry - 12 Oz Glass Bottle
US$4.00Boylan Cane Cola - 12 Oz Glass Bottle
US$4.00Boylan Ginger Ale - 12 Oz Glass Bottle
US$4.00
About
Margherita Pizza Co
Introducing Margherita Pizza Co, a culinary gem located at 112 Charlie Medlin Dr Unit A, Surf City, NC 28445. Known for its wood-fired pizzas and vibrant atmosphere, this restaurant has quickly become a cherished spot for both locals and tourists alike. Guests rave about the cozy setting, where you can watch skilled cooks expertly maneuver the wood oven. The open kitchen adds a theatrical element to your dining experience, making every visit a feast for the senses.
As you settle in, consider pairing your meal with one of the delightful beverages available. Whether it’s an Italian beer or a popular sangria, the drinks are crafted to complement the rich flavors of the food. Diane Veneziale, a satisfied customer, praised the sangria as one of the best she’s tasted, enriched with fresh strawberries and grapefruit.
For starters, don’t miss out on the delectable Diane’s Chicken Meatballs. Her review highlights the melt-in-your-mouth texture, enhanced by a velvety sauce and quality cheese. The portion sizes at Margherita Pizza Co are impressive, with dishes like the Caesar Salad that can easily serve three, making it perfect for sharing.
The true stars at Margherita Pizza Co are the pizzas. Customers have lauded the Queen Margherita and NY Cheese with mushrooms, emphasizing the thin crust that’s cooked to perfection in the wood-fired oven. Lisa Lewin noted that the pizza experience was so satisfying that it earned a spot on her family’s vacation favorites list.
But the culinary journey doesn’t end with the savory offerings. Saving room for dessert is a must; the cheesecake with caramel drizzle is described as indulgent and creamy, rounding off your meal on a high note.
With a focus on fresh ingredients and customer satisfaction, the staff at Margherita Pizza Co deliver exceptional service. From attentive waitstaff to a warm atmosphere, it's clear why guests like Lindsay G are already planning their return visits. So, if you're in Surf City, make sure to pay a visit to Margherita Pizza Co for an unforgettable dining experience that beautifully melds flavor, quality, and a hint of Italian charm.
Book a table